The Chicago Bar Association
Judicial Evaluation Findings
The Chicago Bar Association
Vote Smart Guide
Election Day, Tuesday November 6, 2012

HQ - Highly Qualified
Q - Qualified
NR - Not Recommended
 
Retention Judges - Illinois Appellate Court
Retention Judges - Circuit Court of Cook County
Illinois Supreme - Fitzgerald
Illinois Appellate - Cahill
Illinois Appellate - Coleman
Illinois Appellate - Gallagher
Illinois Appellate - O’Brien
Illinois Appellate - Theis
Illinois Appellate - Tully
Cook Circuit - Conlon
Cook Circuit - Jordan
Cook Circuit - Kinnaird
Cook Circuit - Moran
Cook Circuit - O’Brien, Jr.
Cook Circuit - Frossard
Cook Circuit - Pucinski
Cook Circuit - Simmons, Jr.
Cook Circuit - Stewart
Cook Circuit - Stralka
Cook Circuit - Ward
Cook - Subcircuit 2 - Stuttley
Cook - Subcircuit 3 - McGann
Cook - Subcircuit 3 - Moore
Cook - Subcircuit 4 - Riley
Cook - Subcircuit 4A
Cook - Subcircuit 6 - Delgado
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Jones
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Starks
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Terrell
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Toney
Cook - Subcircuit 8 - Chiola
Cook - Subcircuit 8 - Cole
Cook - Subcircuit 8 - Roy
Cook - Subcircuit 8A
Cook - Subcircuit 9 - Bender
Cook - Subcircuit 9 - Epstein
Cook - Subcircuit 10 - Locallo
Cook - Subcircuit 11 - O’Brien
Cook - Subcircuit 11 - Urso
Cook - Subcircuit 12 - Rochford
Cook - Subcircuit 13 - Pietrucha
Cook - Subcircuit 13A
Cook - Subcircuit 14 - O’Gara
 
Retention Judges - Illinois Appellate Court
# Candidate Finding
201 James Fitzgerald Smith Q

Back to Top
 
Retention Judges - Circuit Court of Cook County
# Candidate Finding
203 Carole Kamin Bellows Q
205 Kathy M. Flanagan Q
207 Moshe Jacobius Q
209 Stuart F. Lubin Q
211 Marvin P. Luckman Q
213 Raymond Funderburk Q
215 Stuart E. Palmer Q
217 Martin S. Agran Q
219 Patricia Banks Q
221 Ronald F. Bartkowicz Q
223 Robert Lopez Cepero Q
225 Garritt E. Howard Q
227 Joseph G. Kazmierski, Jr. Q
229 E. Kenneth Wright, Jr. Q
232 Cynthia Brim NR
234 Rodney Hughes Brooks NR
235 Maureen Elizabeth Connors Q
237 Christopher Donnelly Q
240 James D. Egan NR
241 Catherine Marie Haberkorn Q
244 Lisa Ruble Murphy NR
245 Marya Nega Q
247 Lee Preston Q
249 Drella C. Savage Q
251 James M. Varga Q
253 Richard F. Walsh Q
255 Camille E. Willis Q
257 Marcia Maras Q
259 Peter Flynn Q
261 Paul A. Karkula Q
263 P. Scott Neville, Jr. Q
265 Maura Slattery Boyle Q
267 Mary Margaret Brosnahan Q
269 Matthew E. Coghlan Q
272 Loretta Eadie-Daniels NR
273 Joyce Marie Murphy Gorman Q
275 Joan Margaret O'Brien Q
277 Thomas David Roti Q
279 Colleen F. Sheehan Q
282 Pamela E. Hill-Veal NR
283 Orville E. Hambright Q
285 Michael J. Howlett, Jr. Q
287 Carl Anthony Walker Q
289 Daniel Patrick Brennan Q
292 Gloria Chevere NR
293 Grace G. Dickler Q
295 Ellen L. Flannigan Q
297 Carol M. Howard Q
299 Jill C. Marisie Q
301 James Michael McGing Q
303 Mike McHale Q
305 James Patrick Murphy Q
307 Thomas W. Murphy Q
309 Patrick W. "Pat" O'Brien Q
311 Ramon Ocasio III Q
313 Mary Colleen Roberts Q
315 Diane M. Shelley Q

Back to Top
 
Illinois Supreme Court - Fitzgerald
# Candidate Finding
71 Mary Jane Theis (D) HQ
72 James Gerard Riley (R) Q

Back to Top
 
Illinois Appellate - Cahill
# Candidate Finding
73 Mathias William Delort (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Illinois Appellate - Coleman
# Candidate Finding
74 Nathaniel Roosevelt Howse, Jr. HQ

Back to Top
 
Illinois Appellate - Gallagher
# Candidate Finding
75 P. Scott Neville, Jr. (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Illinois Appellate - O’Brien
# Candidate Finding
76 Jesse G. Reyes (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Illinois Appellate - Theis
# Candidate Finding
77 Maureen Elizabeth Connors (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Illinois Appellate - Tully
# Candidate Finding
78 Terrence J. Lavin (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Conlon
# Candidate Finding
79 Karen Lynn O’Malley D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Jordan
# Candidate Finding
80 Jean Prendergast Rooney (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Kinnaird
# Candidate Finding
81 Erica L. Reddick (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Moran
# Candidate Finding
82 Russell W. Hartigan (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - O’Brien, Jr.
# Candidate Finding
83 Cynthia Ramirez (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Frossard
# Candidate Finding
84 Diann Karen Marsalek (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Pucinski
# Candidate Finding
85 Lorna Ellen Propes (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Simmons, Jr.
# Candidate Finding
86 Jessica A. O’Brien (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Stewart
# Candidate Finding
87 Pamela M. Leeming (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Stralka
# Candidate Finding
88 Michael Tully Mullen (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook Circuit - Ward
# Candidate Finding
89 Elizabeth Mary Hayes (D) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 2 - Stuttley
# Candidate Finding
91 Carl B. Boyd (D) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 3 - McGann
# Candidate Finding
91 Maureen Leahy Delehanty (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 3 - Moore
# Candidate Finding
92 Daniel R. Degnan (D) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 4 - Riley
# Candidate Finding
91 Terry Gallagher (D) Q
92 Harry J. Fournier (R) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 4A
# Candidate Finding
93 Edward M. Maloney (D Q
94 Christine Cook (R) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 6 - Delgado
# Candidate Finding
91 Beatriz Santiago (D) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Jones
# Candidate Finding
91 Aicha Marie MacCarthy (D) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Starks
# Candidate Finding
92 Tommy Brewer (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Terrell
# Candidate Finding
93 William G. Gamboney (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 7 - Toney
# Candidate Finding
94 Kimberly D. Lewis (D) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 8 - Chiola
# Candidate Finding
91 Celia Louise Gamrath (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 8 - Cole
# Candidate Finding
92 John H. Ehrlich (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 8 - Roy
# Candidate Finding
93 Deborah Jean Gubin (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 8A
# Candidate Finding
94 Laura Liu (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 9 - Bender
# Candidate Finding
91 Lionel Jean-Baptiste (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 9 - Epstein
# Candidate Finding
92 Larry G. Axelrood (D) HQ

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 10 - Locallo
# Candidate Finding
91 Thomas R. Allen (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 11 - O’Brien
# Candidate Finding
91 Michael R. Clancy (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 11 - Urso
# Candidate Finding
92 Lisa Ann Marino (D) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 12 - Rochford
# Candidate Finding
91 Andrea M. Schleifer (D) Q
92 James Paul Pieczonka (R) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 13 - Pietrucha
# Candidate Finding
91 Paul S. Pavlus (R) Q

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 13A
# Candidate Finding
92 Martin C. Kelley (R) NR

Back to Top
 
Cook - Subcircuit 14 - O’Gara
# Candidate Finding
91 Regina Ann Scannicchio (D) Q
 
Paid for by The Chicago Bar Association Judicial Evaluation Fund. Copy of the CBA Report is available from the State Board of Elections.

Home News Committee Meeting Schedule Seminar Schedule Need a Lawyer?